We are excited to announce the launch of our new forums! You can access it forums.aavso.org. For questions, please see our blog post. The forums at aavso.org/forum have become read-only.
Since VPHOT transforms magnitudes only and not colors, it looks for Tu, Tb, Tv instead of Tv, Tbv, Tub. So I needed to calculate two additional coefficients: Tu (U as a function of U-B) and Tb (B as a function of B-V). These are:
Tu [U-B] = 0.153
Tb [B-V] = 0.028
plus the original
Tv [B-V] = -0.011
That should give enough information for calculating U,B,V from Sonoita data.
Tu should then = 1.179 + 0.994 = 2.173 which is not good at all.
but your recent posts says
Posted: December 22, 2012 - 11:23am
Since VPHOT transforms magnitudes only and not colors, it looks for Tu, Tb, Tv instead of Tv, Tbv, Tub. So I needed to calculate two additional coefficients: Tu (U as a function of U-B) and Tb (B as a function of B-V). These are:
Tu [U-V] = 0.153
Tb [B-V] = 0.028
plus the original
Tv [B-V] = -0.011
*************
This means Tbv = 0.028 - (-0.022) = 0.039
and Tub = 0.153 - 0.039 = 0.114
As I recall from my photon counting days Tv (epsilon) should be close to zero and Tbv (mu) close to 1.0 and Tub (osi) close to 1.0.
There seems to be some conflicting information or maybe old age has dimmed my reasonng. Can you please set things straight as something does not seem correct. I hope we can get this straight as we have a lot of images for AZ Cas ready for data extraction and reduction.
You are making a basic mistake, equating Tbv to Tb - Tv. The full equations are given in Henden and Kaitchuck, and these two color coefficients were given in my first posting (and are close to 1.0, as you expect). The AID requires that you submit data in magnitude form - that is, U, B, V - rather than the magnitude/color form found in professional literature - V, (B-V), (U-B). Because of this, you need three magnitude coefficients for U,B and V in order to submit those magnitudes as transformed values.
When I do my own photometry, I typically obtain V, (B-V), (U-B) as transformed values, and then submit the magnitudes by proper addition and subtraction of the color indices from V. So for my photometry, I use Tv plus Tbv, Tub. However, VPHOT is not set up that way (yet).
Thanks. I figured it might be something like that. I always use the epsilon, mu and psi for my UBV reduction. I have never used the Tb and Tu coeffieicents.
Thank you so much Arne!
Can these please be uploaded to VPHOT for SRO50? Otherwise I have to re-enter them for every transition I do.
Thanks!
Wayne
When I do the UB transformation, VPHOT is aksing for a Tu value. What do I use?
Can anyone please help with the Tu value?
And can these new values please be uploaded to VPHOT for SRO50?
My work on the AZ Cas project is still on hold.
Thanks!
Wayne
Since VPHOT transforms magnitudes only and not colors, it looks for Tu, Tb, Tv instead of Tv, Tbv, Tub. So I needed to calculate two additional coefficients: Tu (U as a function of U-B) and Tb (B as a function of B-V). These are:
Tu [U-B] = 0.153
Tb [B-V] = 0.028
plus the original
Tv [B-V] = -0.011
That should give enough information for calculating U,B,V from Sonoita data.
Arne
Hi Arne,
On November 7, 2012 - 10:31am You posted
*************
Here are the transformations from this season:
Tv [B-V] = -0.011 +/- 0.005
Tbv = 1.005 +/- 0.015
Tub = 1.179 +/- 0.035
Tb should then = 1.005 + (-0.011) + 0.994
and
Tu should then = 1.179 + 0.994 = 2.173 which is not good at all.
but your recent posts says
Posted: December 22, 2012 - 11:23am
Since VPHOT transforms magnitudes only and not colors, it looks for Tu, Tb, Tv instead of Tv, Tbv, Tub. So I needed to calculate two additional coefficients: Tu (U as a function of U-B) and Tb (B as a function of B-V). These are:
Tu [U-V] = 0.153
Tb [B-V] = 0.028
plus the original
Tv [B-V] = -0.011
*************
This means Tbv = 0.028 - (-0.022) = 0.039
and Tub = 0.153 - 0.039 = 0.114
As I recall from my photon counting days Tv (epsilon) should be close to zero and Tbv (mu) close to 1.0 and Tub (osi) close to 1.0.
There seems to be some conflicting information or maybe old age has dimmed my reasonng. Can you please set things straight as something does not seem correct. I hope we can get this straight as we have a lot of images for AZ Cas ready for data extraction and reduction.
Jeff HPO (187283)
Hi Jeff,
You are making a basic mistake, equating Tbv to Tb - Tv. The full equations are given in Henden and Kaitchuck, and these two color coefficients were given in my first posting (and are close to 1.0, as you expect). The AID requires that you submit data in magnitude form - that is, U, B, V - rather than the magnitude/color form found in professional literature - V, (B-V), (U-B). Because of this, you need three magnitude coefficients for U,B and V in order to submit those magnitudes as transformed values.
When I do my own photometry, I typically obtain V, (B-V), (U-B) as transformed values, and then submit the magnitudes by proper addition and subtraction of the color indices from V. So for my photometry, I use Tv plus Tbv, Tub. However, VPHOT is not set up that way (yet).
Arne
Hi Arne,
Thanks. I figured it might be something like that. I always use the epsilon, mu and psi for my UBV reduction. I have never used the Tb and Tu coeffieicents.
Jeff